Dead Companies
Obituary No. 0057:07 watch5 min read

Lehman Didn't Die From Subprime. This Is What Killed It

In 2007 Lehman Brothers made a record $4.2 billion profit and its CEO was paid $22 million. Twelve months later it filed the largest bankruptcy in history, with $639 billion in assets and 25,000 employees. Everyone blames subprime mortgages. The real killer was $31 borrowed for every $1 it owned, and one bet made at the very top of the market.

7:07

Key moments

  1. 1:45 a.m.
  2. Cotton
  3. The gorilla
  4. The bet
  5. The warning
  6. The weekend
  7. The fallout
  8. The twist

The full story

1:45 a.m.

At one forty-five in the morning on September fifteenth, 2008, lawyers in New York filed a bankruptcy petition for a company with six hundred thirty-nine billion dollars in assets. It was the largest bankruptcy in American history. It still is.

Hours later, employees walked out of the headquarters on Seventh Avenue carrying cardboard boxes, while tourists photographed them. Lehman Brothers was one hundred fifty-eight years old.

The popular story says Lehman died of subprime mortgages. That is only half true. Lehman's fatal bet was something else, and the decision that killed it was made twelve months before the end.

Cotton

In 1844 a young immigrant from Bavaria named Henry Lehman opened a dry goods store in Montgomery, Alabama. His brothers joined him, and by 1850 the sign over the door read Lehman Brothers.

Farmers paid in cotton, so the brothers became cotton traders. Cotton took them to New York, and trading cotton became trading everything. By the twentieth century, Lehman was financing railroads, department stores and television networks.

It survived the Civil War, the crash of 1929 and the Great Depression. In 1984 American Express swallowed it, then spun it back out in 1994 as a small bank Wall Street expected to be eaten within a year.

The gorilla

It was not eaten. The man who ran it, Richard Fuld, had joined as a trader in 1969 and had a nickname on the trading floor: the gorilla. His rule was simple. Lehman would never be the victim again.

For fourteen years he was right. Lehman grew from a bond shop into the fourth largest investment bank in America. By 2007 it had about twenty-eight thousand employees and record profits.

In 2007 Lehman earned a record four point two billion dollars. Its shares hit eighty-six dollars, the firm was worth close to sixty billion, and Fuld was paid twenty-two million dollars.

The engine was borrowed money. For every dollar of its own capital, Lehman was using about thirty-one dollars of other people's. On Wall Street this is called leverage. Everywhere else it is called a tightrope.

At thirty-one to one, a fall of just three percent in the value of what you own wipes out everything you have. Lehman had chosen to walk the rope in a storm.

The bet

Everyone knows Lehman was deep in subprime mortgages. It owned two mortgage lenders and packaged home loans into bonds by the billions. But in 2007 it made a bigger bet.

In 2007, with the housing market already cracking, Lehman agreed to buy Archstone, one of America's largest apartment landlords, for about twenty-two billion dollars. The deal closed that October, with Lehman holding much of the risk.

While rivals pulled back from real estate, Lehman doubled down on commercial property. Fuld believed the panic was temporary and the brave would be rewarded. By early 2008, Lehman held tens of billions in property it could not sell.

The warning

In March 2008 Bear Stearns, the fifth largest investment bank, collapsed in a week and was sold for a tiny fraction of its value, with the Federal Reserve absorbing the risk. Wall Street asked: who is next?

The answer was obvious. Lehman had the same business, the same leverage, and more real estate. Its share price fell by nearly half in a single morning before recovering.

Inside the bank, the response was not to shrink. It was to hide. For three straight quarters, Lehman used an accounting maneuver called Repo one-oh-five to move up to fifty billion dollars of assets off its books for a few days.

The assets were temporarily sold, and bought back right after the quarter closed. To investors, the tightrope looked shorter than it was. A court-appointed examiner would later call the practice materially misleading.

In June 2008 Lehman reported its first quarterly loss since going public: two point eight billion dollars. It raised six billion in fresh capital. It was not enough. Nothing was going to be enough.

Through August, Fuld hunted for a savior. Korea Development Bank was interested, but the two sides could not agree on a price. On September ninth, the Koreans walked away. Lehman's stock fell forty-five percent in a day.

On September tenth Lehman announced a third-quarter loss of three point nine billion dollars and a plan to spin off its real estate. Nobody believed it. By Friday the shares were below four dollars.

The weekend

That weekend the heads of every major bank were summoned to the Federal Reserve in lower Manhattan. Two buyers were in the room: Bank of America, and Barclays of Britain.

Bank of America walked away and bought Merrill Lynch instead. Barclays wanted Lehman, but British regulators would not let it guarantee Lehman's trades without a shareholder vote that would take weeks. There were no weeks.

Six months earlier the government had backed the rescue of Bear Stearns. The next day it would rescue the insurer AIG with eighty-five billion dollars. For Lehman, it said no.

On Monday, shares that had traded at eighty-six dollars closed at twenty-one cents. The Dow fell more than five hundred points, its worst day since the attacks of September eleventh.

The fallout

Within days Barclays bought Lehman's American business, including the Seventh Avenue tower, for about one point three five billion dollars. Nomura of Japan took Europe and Asia. The name came off the building within a week.

The bankruptcy dwarfed every one before it. Enron and WorldCom, the scandals of the previous decade, were a fraction of its size.

The shock did what regulators feared. Money market funds broke the buck, lending between banks froze, and within three weeks Congress passed a seven hundred billion dollar bailout for everyone else.

Unwinding Lehman took more than a decade. Creditors eventually recovered well over one hundred billion dollars, paid out in installments over fourteen years.

The twist

Now here is the twist. Lehman's subprime losses were real, but Merrill Lynch lost more on mortgages, and Merrill survived. Morgan Stanley nearly died the same week, and survived. What made Lehman different?

Two things. The real estate it bought at the top of the market, when it could have sold. And a simple fact: a bank borrowing thirty-one dollars for every one it owns does not die of losses. It dies the moment lenders stop believing.

Fuld later told Congress he would wonder for the rest of his life why Lehman was the only firm not saved. The examiner found something simpler: Lehman's leaders knew the risk, doubled down, and then dressed up the numbers.

The brothers from Alabama had built a bank that survived every crisis for a hundred and fifty years by being the one that did not panic. In 2008, not panicking was the only thing it did wrong.

So did Lehman die because of subprime mortgages? No. It borrowed thirty-one dollars for every one it owned, bet them on buildings at the top of the market, and hid the result until the only people left to call could say no.

Sources

Photo credits

Real photos in the video and its thumbnail:

Narration is an AI voice. Real photos are credited; other images are AI-generated illustrations.

Up next
  • Obituary No. 0087:05

    Pan Am Owned the Sky. One Rule Killed It

    Pan Am launched the jet age, ordered the first 25 Boeing 747s for $525 million, and was the most famous airline on Earth. Then it spent a decade selling everything it owned to stay alive. On December 4, 1991, its last flight landed in Miami. The bomb over Lockerbie didn't kill Pan Am. A rule written in 1927 did.

  • Obituary No. 0076:52

    Nokia Built a Touchscreen Phone in 2004, Then Killed It

    In 2007 Nokia sold 4 out of every 10 phones on Earth and more than half of all smartphones. Six years later its phone business was sold to Microsoft for $7.2 billion, and two years after that Microsoft wrote almost all of it off. Nokia had a touchscreen phone with an app store in 2004. This is why it never shipped.

  • Obituary No. 0067:20

    MySpace Wasn't Killed by Facebook. It Was a $900M Deal

    In 2006 MySpace was the most visited website in America, bigger than Google, with 100 million accounts. Five years later it sold for $35 million, a 94% loss for News Corp. Facebook didn't kill it. A $900 million Google deal did, and almost nobody noticed at the time.